Nave News
Nave Law wins suit against City of Albany to protect Reverend’s civil rights.
As part of Nave Law Firm’s efforts to give back to the communities we practice in, our own Derek Andrews took action after reading a Times Union article about a local woman’s plight against a local government who stonewalled her efforts to obtain body camera recordings of an incident that involved her.
In 2019, uniformed members of the Albany Police Department wearing body cameras forcibly removed Reverend Cheryl Hawkins, a street-reach minister in the New York Capital District, from a public park as she preached and sang Christian hymns, for which she had received a special event permit from the City of Albany. That removal violated her constitutionally-guaranteed rights to free expression. As part of a lawsuit, her civil rights attorney requested those body camera recordings from the city through New York’s Freedom of Information Law but was rebuffed, having been told that they were protected and confidential because of Civil Rights Law Section 50-a.
Mr. Andrews helped both Ms. Hawkins and her civil rights attorney by filing an Article 78 special proceeding, a type of lawsuit, against the City of Albany and the Albany Police Department, claiming that they violated Ms. Hawkins’ right to free access to body camera recordings of that incident.
Although the city produced those recordings before the conclusion of the lawsuit, Judge David Weinstein of the Albany County Supreme Court agreed with Mr. Andrews’ arguments when he issued a decision at the end of 2020 stating that Ms. Hawkins had substantially prevailed and that the city was unreasonable in originally denying her access. That last part meant that the city Times Union Article, which resulted in a five-figure settlement. Ms. Hawkins will now continue her lawsuit against Albany for violating her civil rights.
When asked for comment by Reverand Hawkins, she responded:
“Mr. Andrews saw the Times-Union Newspaper Front Page Huge Article (February 17, 2020). He then contacted my attorney and wanted to see how he could help. He felt that I was facing an injustice. I was already paying another lawyer big money to represent me, and I could not afford a second law firm. Derek then spoke with the leadership team with Nave Law Firm, and the team decided to take the case at no cost to me.
I was so grateful that he believed in me enough to advocate for me and cared enough to help me at no cost.
The best part is that he WON THE CASE; he even won the city’s and the cop’s appeal filed in Albany County after winning the case.”
Nave Law Firm is grateful for the opportunity to have assisted Ms. Hawkins in her pursuit of justice.
Talents working together with a collective energy to help solve every day people problems.
Nave Law Firm is a team of skilled attorneys, paralegals, legal assistants, and advocates dedicated to providing clients with a high-caliber, legal representation to achieve successful results. At Nave Law Firm, We understand that every client’s situation is unique, so we never offer a one-size-fits-all solution. Sounds simple, but by focusing on solving everyday people problems, we’ve developed a reputation for compassion, honesty, and positive results that set us apart from the other firms.
sentation
Our honest, transparent approach to client representation helps us better protect our clients.
With more than 100 years of experience, we leverage our insight to benefit our clients.
We are dedicated to being a faithful and reliable support system for our clients.
what our clients are saying
Honest great lawyer, and very empathetic and reasonable. Their Willingness to work with you and help is amazing. Would highly recommend. Not one of those slimy lawyers that milk every dime they can out of you. One of the good ones.
The entire team at Nave Law is second to none. They are dedicated, hard working and responsive. During my experience I felt as if I was their only client. Communication was exceptional as well as the dedication and attention to my case. Thank you all for everything!
Fast, honest and professional. I had court in 3 days and was about loose my license and Nave Law firm took care of everything and I didn’t even have to go to court. They were worth every penny and I will recommend them to everyone. Thank you again Nave law Firm!
Filled with hard-working employees and highly communicative about the information that they need from their clients, Nave Law Firm treats your matters with friendly manners and seriousness towards the situation. My case was handled with detail and I never felt as though I was being neglected.
It’s hard to see the “light” after you’re in such an awful position. It’s important to choose a team who will literally be by your side through it all. Working with this firm was the best decision I could have made.